This recent season, I found myself navigating in congested traffic on the scorching streets of Marseille. At an intersection, my companion in the front seat advised a right turn toward a renowned spot for bouillabaisse. However, the digital guide on my phone instructed us to continue straight. Weary and overheated, I heeded the app's directive. Moments later, we were stuck at a roadwork site.
A seemingly trivial event, maybe. But one that captures a defining dilemma of our era, where technology touches almost every aspect of our lives: whom do we trust to a greater degree – other people and our personal instincts, or the algorithm?
A Call for Intellectual Maturity and Our Modern Relapse
The renowned German philosopher Immanuel Kant famously described the Enlightenment as "man's release from its self-inflicted nonage." This immaturity, he wrote, "represents the incapacity to use one's personal reason without direction from an external source." For centuries, that guiding "other" for human thought was often the priest, the king, or the landowner – figures claiming to speak for divine will. To comprehend natural events like volcanic eruptions, people sought answers in theology. In shaping the social world, from economics to love, religious doctrine served as the main compass.
“Sapere aude!” or “Have courage to use your own understanding!”
Kant maintained that humans always possessed the ability to think rationally. They simply lacked the boldness to employ it. With upheavals in the 18th century, a new dawn emerged: logic would replace blind faith, and the human mind, freed from authority, would become the driver of progress and a better world.
Today, 250 years later, one might question if we are quietly regressing into a state of intellectual immaturity. An app dictating a direction is just one example. AI threatens to become our new "other" – a unseen overseer that steers our choices and behaviors. We risk relinquishing the historically earned autonomy to think independently – and this time, not to gods or kings, but to computer programs.
The Rapid Rise and Subtle Dangers of AI Dependence
ChatGPT was launched only in 2022, and already a global survey found that an vast number of respondents had engaged with artificial intelligence in the previous six months. Whether contemplating ending a relationship or choosing a candidate, individuals are increasingly turning to algorithms for counsel. Research suggests a large majority of user queries relate to personal life matters. Even more striking than our reliance on AI for advice is what happens when we let it express for us. Composition is now among the top uses for generative AI, just behind practical requests. The celebrated American author Joan Didion famously said, “I write purely to discover what I am thinking.” What occurs when we cease writing? Do we lose that path?
Worryingly, some evidence hints the outcome may be yes. A study conducted by the Massachusetts Institute of Technology used brain monitoring to track the cognitive activity of essay writers who had access to AI, Google, or no aids. Those who could use AI displayed the least cognitive engagement and had difficulty accurately recalling their own work. Perhaps most troubling was that over time, individuals in the AI group grew progressively lazier, pasting entire blocks of text.
“Laziness and cowardice,” Kant wrote, “are the reasons why so many of men … stay in lifelong immaturity.”
Of course, AI's attraction stems from its convenience. It saves time, minimizes work and – importantly – offers a novel way to abdicate responsibility. In his 1941 book, Escape from Freedom, the German psychoanalyst Erich Fromm argued that the rise of fascism could be understood by a preference to surrender personal freedom in exchange for the reassuring certainty of obedience. AI offers a modern method of surrendering the weight of having to think and choose.
The Opacity Dilemma: Trust Without Understanding
AI's primary draw is its ability to accomplish things outside our minds – sifting through oceans of data at lightning pace. Sitting in the car in Marseille, this was, ultimately, why I chose to trust the machine over my companion (a decision she took as an affront). With access to all the data, surely the algorithm had superior insight – or so I believed.
The core issue is that AI operates as a opaque system. It produces answers, but without necessarily fostering human comprehension. We do not truly know how AI reaches its decisions – even its programmers admit this. Nor can we verify its logic against clear, objective criteria. So when we heed AI's recommendation, we are not being led by logic. We are returning to the domain of faith. In dubio pro machina: when in doubt, side with the machine – that may become our 21st-century guiding principle.
Using Without Losing: The Critical Balance
AI can be a formidable ally for humanity in scientific pursuit. It can aid in medical research, free us from "bullshit jobs", or manage taxes – duties that are repetitive and offer little satisfaction. All to the good. But Kant and his peers did not champion reason over faith just so humans could optimize chores or have extra free time. Independent thought was not merely about productivity – it was a discipline of freedom and human emancipation.
Human thought is inherently messy and error-prone, but it compels us to argue, to question, to challenge concepts – and to recognize the boundaries of our own knowledge. It fosters self-reliance, both individually and as a society. For Kant, the exercise of reason was never solely about acquiring knowledge; it was about empowering people to become agents of their own lives, and to resist control. It was about building a ethical society grounded in the common foundation of rational discourse, rather than blind belief.
With all the advantages AI brings, the key question is this: how can we leverage its potential of superhuman intelligence without eroding human reasoning, the cornerstone of the Enlightenment and of free societies themselves? That is likely one of the central dilemmas of our century. It is a question we would do well not to outsource to the machine.